paper-quality-check

Audit research papers across eight quality dimensions and generate a structured report.

Updated Mar 27, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/EmaRimoldi/Claude-scholar-extended --skill paper-quality-check
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: paper-quality-check
Source: https://github.com/EmaRimoldi/Claude-scholar-extended/tree/main/skills/paper-quality-check
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/EmaRimoldi/Claude-scholar-extended --skill paper-quality-check

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Audit a research paper against eight quality dimensions to ensure rigor and reproducibility across stages of the pipeline.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Comprehensive eight-dimension quality audit covering claim-evidence alignment, statistical rigor, baselines, generalizability, mechanistic validation, error analysis, presentation accuracy, and reproducibility.
  • Works with partial artifacts (plans, results, drafts) or full manuscripts and can be invoked at multiple pipeline steps.
  • Generates a structured quality report and integration-ready feedback for manuscript revision and pipeline validation.

Quick Start

Invoke the paper-quality-check skill after design, analysis, or manuscript steps to generate a comprehensive quality report.

Frequently Asked Questions about paper-quality-check

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I audit a research paper for statistical rigor and reproducibility?

Audit a research paper by evaluating it against eight quality dimensions including statistical rigor, baselines, and reproducibility to generate a structured report verifying claim-evidence alignment and mechanistic validation.

What does a research paper quality check cover besides statistical rigor?

A research paper quality check covers eight dimensions: claim-evidence alignment, statistical rigor, baselines, generalizability, mechanistic validation, error analysis, presentation accuracy, and reproducibility, aggregating findings into a structured report.

Can I run a quality audit on a partial manuscript or draft before submission?

Yes, you can run a quality audit on partial artifacts such as plans, results, or drafts. The audit works at multiple pipeline steps after design, analysis, or manuscript preparation to verify rigor and reproducibility.

How do I verify claim-evidence alignment and generalizability in my research paper?

Verify claim-evidence alignment and generalizability by applying structured checks across eight quality dimensions, which aggregate findings into a formal report with integration-ready feedback for manuscript revision.

What is the best way to check baselines and error analysis in a research manuscript?

The best way to check baselines and error analysis is to audit the manuscript against eight quality dimensions, enforcing structured checks that generate a comprehensive report for pipeline validation and revision.

When should I perform a reproducibility and quality audit during my research pipeline?

Perform a reproducibility and quality audit after designing experiments, analyzing results, or preparing the manuscript to verify presentation accuracy, mechanistic validation, and overall statistical rigor before submission.