paper-review-sim

To simulate a peer review panel, this Skill automates a five-reviewer persona process to stress-test your research manuscript. It evaluates methodology, results, and presentation by verifying quantitative claims against concrete evaluation data.

An automated LLM-review checks for methodology robustness, data verification, and presentation quality. It enforces evidence-based evaluation by requiring every quantitative claim in your draft to link directly to concrete results under the results/evaluation directory.

To trigger the paper review simulation, invoke the explicit /paper-review-sim command. You must provide your paper draft path via ARGUMENTS or place the draft at docs/paper_draft.md for the five reviewer personas to process.

Yes, you can use this peer-review simulation for major methodology revisions and pre-submission robustness checks. It applies HPC, ML, Stats, Reproducibility, and Devil's Advocate personas to stress-test your draft against expected objections.

You need to format your evaluation data under a results/evaluation/ directory. The review process enforces evidence-based evaluation, meaning every quantitative claim in your paper draft must link to concrete data located within this specific path.