review-proposal

Name: review-proposal
Availability: InStock
Author: max-loo

Identify contradictions, gaps, and risks in user-provided proposals.

2|Updated Oct 13, 2025

Search Tags:#design #architecture #review #quality-assurance #proposal #critique #risk-analysis

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/Max-Loo/multi-chat --skill review-proposal-max-loo

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: review-proposal
Source: https://github.com/Max-Loo/multi-chat/tree/main/.opencode/skills/review-proposal
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Max-Loo/multi-chat --skill review-proposal-max-loo

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Identifies contradictions, gaps, and optimization opportunities in proposals, designs, or architecture plans to reduce risk and improve outcomes.

Core Features & Use Cases

Structured critique framework: assesses logical consistency, assumption validity, and feasibility.
Cross-domain applicability: suitable for software architecture, product design, and implementation roadmaps.
Actionable outputs: documents issues with rationales and concrete improvement suggestions.

Quick Start

Upload or paste a proposal, design document, or architecture plan and ask this skill to perform a deep review.

Frequently Asked Questions about review-proposal

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I review an architecture proposal for logical gaps and risks?▼

To review an architecture proposal, use a structured critique framework that assesses logical consistency, assumption validity, and feasibility. This process identifies contradictions and documents issues with concrete rationales and improvement suggestions.

What is the best way to critique an implementation plan before development?▼

The best way to critique an implementation plan is through a deep review that enforces a rigorous workflow, cites evidence for each finding, and suggests concrete mitigations to reduce project risk and optimize outcomes.

Can I use a proposal review tool for both software design and product roadmaps?▼

Yes, you can use this proposal review approach for both software design and product roadmaps. It offers cross-domain applicability, meaning it effectively evaluates implementation plans and organizational contexts beyond just software architecture.

How do you identify contradictions in a design document?▼

You identify contradictions in a design document by applying a structured critique framework that enforces a rigorous workflow. This method assesses logical consistency and cites specific evidence for every identified flaw or gap.

What are the limitations of using an automated critique for project proposals?▼

The critique relies entirely on the user-provided proposal text, meaning it cannot assess external environmental factors or undocumented dependencies. Its effectiveness is bounded by the clarity, completeness, and accuracy of the submitted design documents.