skill-judge

Assess Skill units against an 8-dimensional scoring framework and generate structured evaluation reports.

Updated Aug 27, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Within-7/minto-plugin-tools --skill skill-judge-within-7
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: skill-judge
Source: https://github.com/Within-7/minto-plugin-tools/tree/main/skill-judge
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Within-7/minto-plugin-tools --skill skill-judge-within-7

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

The Skill Judge provides a rigorous, repeatable method to evaluate Skill units for quality, compliance, and usability, ensuring every Skill has a clear activation frontmatter and actionable guidance.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • 8-dimensional scoring framework (D1-D8) with explicit weightings and grade mapping.
  • Layered loading guidance (progressive disclosure) with mandatory and do-not-load triggers.
  • Frontmatter and description validation against official references (references/evaluation-guide.md and references/scoring-guide.md).
  • Structured reporting including dimension scores, critical issues, improvement suggestions, and strengths.
  • Use cases: auditing existing Skills for compliance; guiding improvements to new skills; benchmarking Skill quality during deployment.

Quick Start

Run the Skill Judge on a Skill unit directory to generate a standardized evaluation report. It references the official guides in references/ to ensure alignment with criteria.

Frequently Asked Questions about skill-judge

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I evaluate skill quality using a structured scoring framework?

You evaluate skill quality by assessing units against an 8-dimensional scoring framework to produce structured evaluation reports. It analyzes frontmatter validity, description quality, and pattern adherence to generate dimension scores and improvement suggestions.

What is skill frontmatter validation and how does it work?

Skill frontmatter validation checks a skill's activation metadata against official reference guides to ensure compliance. It verifies frontmatter structure and description quality to confirm the skill has clear activation triggers and actionable guidance.

How do I audit existing skills for compliance and deployment readiness?

You audit existing skills by running the evaluation on a skill unit directory to generate a standardized report. It uses official references to benchmark compliance, outputting critical issues, strengths, and a formal evaluation summary suitable for deployment reviews.

Does this skill evaluation tool require any external dependencies?

No, this skill evaluation tool requires no external dependencies to assess skill quality. It operates self-contained using internal official reference guides to validate frontmatter and score dimensions without needing additional packages.

What's the best way to generate a structured report for skill quality assurance?

The best way to generate a structured QA report is to run this evaluation framework on a skill directory. It outputs formal evaluation summaries including dimension scores, critical issues, and improvement suggestions aligned with official benchmarking references.

When should I avoid using an automated scoring framework for skill evaluation?

You should avoid using an automated scoring framework when evaluating highly subjective or experimental skill designs that lack standardized frontmatter. The framework relies on strict pattern adherence and progressive disclosure triggers to benchmark quality accurately.