paper-review

Assists in self-reviewing academic paper drafts with structured checklists and feedback.

122|19|Updated Dec 2, 2024
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/AI4Scientist/nano-scientist --skill paper-review-ai4scientist
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: paper-review
Source: https://github.com/AI4Scientist/nano-scientist/tree/main/skills/paper-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/AI4Scientist/nano-scientist --skill paper-review-ai4scientist

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

Guides researchers to self-review their own academic papers before submission, enabling rigorous pre-submission critique and improvement.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • 5-aspect self-review checklist covering contribution sufficiency, writing clarity, experimental results quality, testing completeness, and method design.
  • Reverse-outlining technique to verify narrative flow and section coherence.
  • References-based guidance with linked materials to prepare for reviewer scrutiny and rebuttal planning.
  • Use cases include pre-submission drafts, stress-testing claims, and preparing for reviewer questions.

Quick Start

Provide your draft and run through the 5-aspect checklist to surface improvements.

Frequently Asked Questions about paper-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I self-review my academic paper before submission?

Self-review an academic paper before submission by applying a 5-aspect checklist covering contribution, clarity, results, testing, and method design to stress-test claims and guide improvements.

What is reverse outlining and how does it verify narrative flow?

Reverse outlining is a technique to verify narrative flow and section coherence by extracting the core claim from each paragraph to ensure logical progression throughout the academic paper.

How do I stress-test academic claims for peer review preparation?

Stress-test academic claims for peer review preparation by conducting adversarial testing against your own arguments, surfacing potential vulnerabilities to anticipate and address reviewer scrutiny.

Can I use this self-review checklist for pre-submission drafts across different disciplines?

Yes, this self-review checklist is applicable to pre-submission drafting across disciplines, enabling structured critique of contribution sufficiency and experimental quality regardless of the specific academic field.

How do I prepare for reviewer scrutiny and rebuttal planning?

Prepare for reviewer scrutiny and rebuttal planning by utilizing linked references-based guidance to anticipate reviewer questions and structuring your defense against potential methodological critiques.

What is the best way to assess submission readiness for an academic manuscript?

The best way to assess submission readiness is running through a 5-aspect self-review checklist that evaluates writing clarity, experimental completeness, and method design to surface necessary improvements.