paper-review

Analyze academic manuscripts in PDF or Markdown for methodological rigor and statistical validity.

42|7|Updated Mar 23, 2026

Search Tags:#statistics #PDF #peer review #research evaluation #manuscript analysis #scientific review

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/neuromechanist/research-skills --skill paper-review-neuromechanist

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: paper-review
Source: https://github.com/neuromechanist/research-skills/tree/main/plugins/manuscript/skills/paper-review
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/neuromechanist/research-skills --skill paper-review-neuromechanist

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

💡 This Skill includes references (resource) components.

What problem does it solve?

This Skill streamlines the peer review process of academic manuscripts by providing automated, structured feedback focusing on methodological soundness, statistical validity, and clarity.

Core Features & Use Cases

Structured Manuscript Analysis: Guides users through comprehensive review of PDF or Markdown formatted research papers, including figures and supplementary materials.
Methodology and Statistical Evaluation: Assists in assessing experimental design, data analysis, and statistical appropriateness based on detailed checklists and guidelines.
Use Case: A reviewer receives a research paper as a PDF and, using this Skill, extracts key sections, evaluates the methodological rigor, and generates a detailed, balanced review with specific recommendations.

Quick Start

Upload the PDF of your manuscript and activate the paper-review skill to receive a detailed evaluation of its methods, figures, and literature coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions about paper-review

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I perform automated peer review on an academic manuscript PDF?▼

To perform automated peer review on an academic manuscript, upload your PDF or Markdown file and activate the review process. The system evaluates research quality, statistical validity, and writing clarity to generate structured feedback.

What does statistical validity evaluation check in a research paper?▼

Statistical validity evaluation checks experimental design and data analysis appropriateness in a research paper using detailed guidelines. It assesses methodological rigor to ensure scientific reproducibility and proper literature citation.

Can I analyze Markdown files for methodological rigor or does it only support PDF?▼

You can analyze both Markdown files and PDF documents for methodological rigor. The manuscript analysis evaluates experimental design and statistical appropriateness across both formats, including figures and supplementary materials.

What is the best way to generate constructive feedback for a scientific manuscript?▼

The best way to generate constructive feedback for a scientific manuscript is using automated structured analysis. It extracts key sections and evaluates methodological soundness to deliver specific recommendations and ensure research reproducibility.

Does manuscript analysis work for evaluating literature coverage in scientific writing?▼

Yes, manuscript analysis works for evaluating literature coverage in scientific writing. It assesses proper literature citation and research quality, guiding reviewers to ensure comprehensive methodological evaluation and balanced feedback.

Are there limitations when assessing experimental design in research papers?▼

A limitation when assessing experimental design is that the evaluation relies entirely on the provided manuscript text and figures. It cannot independently verify raw data or replicate the statistical results mentioned in the document.