rebuttal

Generate grounded, venue-compliant rebuttal drafts from external reviews.

1|Updated Mar 24, 2026
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/kitcaf/skills --skill rebuttal-kitcaf
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: rebuttal
Source: https://github.com/kitcaf/skills/tree/main/skills/skills-codex/skills/rebuttal
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/kitcaf/skills --skill rebuttal-kitcaf

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

Automatically generate grounded, venue-compliant rebuttals from external reviews for a submitted paper.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Parses external reviews and aligns them with the paper and venue constraints
  • Enforces grounding, completeness, and safe drafting under venue limits
  • Manages follow-up rounds and versioned state for post-submission communications

Quick Start

Provide the paper, raw reviews, and venue rules to generate an initial rebuttal draft.

Frequently Asked Questions about rebuttal

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I automatically generate a rebuttal for an ICML paper submission?

To generate an ICML rebuttal, you provide your paper, raw reviews, and venue rules. The system parses external reviews and aligns them with paper constraints to produce a venue-compliant rebuttal draft.

How does grounded rebuttal drafting work for machine learning conferences?

Grounded rebuttal drafting works by enforcing provenance and commitment gates against the original paper text. It ensures honesty and prevents hallucinations by validating that all claims in the rebuttal are traceable to the source material.

Can I manage multiple reviewers and follow-up rounds in an automated rebuttal workflow?

Yes, you can manage multiple reviewers and follow-up rounds. The system tracks versioned state for post-submission communications, ensuring coverage and safety across all reviewer interactions and subsequent replies.

Does automated rebuttal generation enforce venue character limits and safety constraints?

Automated rebuttal generation enforces strict venue limits and safety validations. Configurable constants ensure the structured output complies with text-only submission requirements and does not exceed allowed lengths.

What is needed to start drafting venue-ready rebuttals from external reviews?

You need your submitted paper, the raw text of external reviews, and the specific venue rules. Providing these inputs allows the system to initialize state tracking and generate an initial rebuttal draft.

Why do I need grounding and provenance checks when responding to peer reviews?

You need grounding and provenance checks to maintain academic honesty and accuracy. They prevent unverified claims in your response, ensuring that commitments and corrections align strictly with your original submission.