skills.rest
raja21068
raja21068COMMUNITY
Explore all skills by this author →
WebsiteGitHub

rebuttal

Parse external reviews into atomic issues and draft venue-compliant rebuttals.

2|1|Updated Apr 19, 2026
Search Tags:#academic writing#peer review#conference submission#rebuttal#evidence grounding#OpenReview#argument coverage
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/raja21068/AutoResearch --skill rebuttal-raja21068
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: rebuttal
Source: https://github.com/raja21068/AutoResearch/tree/main/skills/aris/rebuttal
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/raja21068/AutoResearch --skill rebuttal-raja21068

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

This Skill helps you transform external reviewer feedback into a grounded, venue-compliant rebuttal that addresses every concern safely without inventing new evidence or overcommitting.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Review parsing and issue atomization: Converts raw reviews into an ISSUE_BOARD with atomic concerns, severity, stance, and response-mode guidance.
  • Strategy planning with guardrails: Builds a STRATEGY_PLAN that assigns global themes, evidence needs, reviewer priorities, and character/word budgeting by venue mode.
  • Text-only rebuttal drafting with safety gates: Drafts single-document or per-reviewer-thread responses while enforcing provenance, commitments, and full coverage.
  • Optional stress-testing via Codex MCP: Runs structured checks to catch unsupported statements, unsafe promises, tone issues, and missing coverage.
  • Follow-up round management: Appends new reviews to a follow-up log and generates delta replies while updating the revision checklist.

Quick Start

Use the rebuttal skill to reply to reviewers from your paper and raw review bundle: run /rebuttal "paper/" — venue: ICML, character limit: 5000.

Frequently Asked Questions about rebuttal

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I write an academic rebuttal for OpenReview without fabricating evidence?▼

To write a safe rebuttal, parse external reviews into atomic issues and draft evidence-grounded responses that map provenance to your paper. This approach enforces venue rules and blocks unapproved claims, preventing fabrication during conference submission.

Can I reply to individual reviewers in ICML-style post-submission threads?▼

Yes, you can generate per-reviewer thread replies or a single shared response. The system plans evidence-backed responses by assigning reviewer priorities and character budgets based on the specified venue mode.

How do I manage follow-up rounds when new reviews are posted on OpenReview?▼

Manage follow-up rounds by appending new reviews to a follow-up log. The system generates delta replies addressing new concerns while updating the revision checklist to track outstanding issues.

What is the best way to ensure my peer review rebuttal covers every reviewer concern?▼

Ensure full argument coverage by converting raw reviews into an issue board with atomic concerns and severity levels. Strategy planning assigns global themes and evidence needs to guarantee no reviewer issue is missed.

Does the rebuttal drafting process enforce character and word limits for conference submissions?▼

Yes, strategy planning includes explicit character and word budgeting by venue mode. You must provide venue rules and limits before drafting to ensure the generated rebuttal text complies with submission constraints.

How do I stress-test my reviewer rebuttal for unsupported statements before submitting?▼

Stress-test your rebuttal using structured checks to catch unsupported statements, unsafe promises, tone issues, and missing coverage. This validates that all commitments and provenance mappings are safe before final submission.

Related Skills

Explore More Education & Research Skills→
catlog22catlog22
76

scholar-review

Parse reviewer comments and generate structured rebuttal and revision plans.

Community
Advanced
SamyakJhaveriSamyakJhaveri

rebuttal

Organize reviewer feedback and draft venue-compliant rebuttals with evidence.

Community
Advanced
rongarederongarede
4

paper-readbook

Reverse-engineer academic papers into Design Canvas, Layered Reverse Outline, and Argument Mining Notes.

Community
Advanced
zhuyingqinzhuyingqin
1

rebuttal

Generate venue-compliant rebuttal drafts from paper source and reviewer feedback.

Community
Advanced