Verified:GitHub

rebuttal

Generate venue-compliant rebuttal drafts from paper source and reviewer feedback.

1|1|Updated May 19, 2026

Search Tags:#peer review #rebuttal #coverage tracking #text-only response #ICML NeurIPS #evidence grounded writing #MCP stress test

Ready to run

npx skills add https://github.com/zhuyingqin/ARIS-WEB --skill rebuttal-zhuyingqin

💬 Prompt for ChatGPT / Claude Chat▼

Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: rebuttal
Source: https://github.com/zhuyingqin/ARIS-WEB/tree/main/crates/runtime/assets/skills/rebuttal
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/zhuyingqin/ARIS-WEB --skill rebuttal-zhuyingqin

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

It helps you convert external reviewer feedback into a grounded, venue-compliant rebuttal that answers every concern without inventing evidence or making unsafe promises.

Core Features & Use Cases

Review parsing & issue board creation: normalizes raw reviews into atomic concerns with severity, stance, priority, and response-mode planning.
Strategy planning with strict gates: builds a character/word-budget plan and enforces provenance, commitment, and coverage so nothing disappears.
Venue-mode rebuttal drafting: produces either one shared paste-ready response or per-reviewer self-contained thread replies, then stress-tests the draft via Codex MCP.

Quick Start

Use the rebuttal skill to turn your pasted reviews and venue rules into a paste-ready rebuttal by running: /rebuttal "paper/" -- venue: ICML -- character limit: 5000

Frequently Asked Questions about rebuttal

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema

How do I draft an ICML or NeurIPS reviewer rebuttal that stays within the character limit?▼

To draft an ICML or NeurIPS reviewer rebuttal within the character limit, this skill builds a character/word-budget plan that enforces provenance and coverage gates while generating a paste-ready, text-only response.

How do I track coverage and ensure every reviewer concern is addressed in a rebuttal?▼

To track coverage and ensure every reviewer concern is addressed, this skill parses raw reviews into an issue board with severity, stance, and priority, enforcing strict commitment gates so nothing disappears.

Can I generate per-reviewer thread replies instead of a single shared rebuttal response?▼

Yes, you can generate per-reviewer thread replies. This skill supports both single-document author responses and self-contained per-reviewer thread replies, handling multiple reviewers and follow-up rounds.

What is the best way to prevent fabricating evidence when writing a peer review rebuttal?▼

To prevent fabricating evidence when writing a peer review rebuttal, this skill enforces provenance gates and optional evidence bridging, grounding all replies strictly in the paper source and external reviewer feedback.

Does the rebuttal drafting process support stress testing the draft before submission?▼

Yes, the rebuttal drafting process supports stress testing. It optionally runs Codex MCP stress tests on the venue-compliant draft to validate the text-only replies without fabricating evidence.

Do I need to provide the paper source to generate a venue-compliant rebuttal?▼

Yes, you need to provide the paper source. This skill generates a grounded, venue-compliant rebuttal response by bridging external reviewer feedback with the original paper source to ensure provenance.