skills.rest
Collectively-Gary
Collectively-GaryOFFICIAL
Explore all skills by this author →
GitHub

review-plan / code-pr

Reviews code-pr plans for clone steps, deterministic approach, and weighted rubric approval.

Updated Aug 27, 2026
Search Tags:#pull request#github#test plan#agentic workflows#plan review#rubric scoring#deterministic approach
One-click install
npx skills add https://github.com/Collectively-Gary/GaryOS --skill review-plan-code-pr
Or copy as Structured Prompt for Agent▼
Please help me install this Agent Skill.
Skill: review-plan / code-pr
Source: https://github.com/Collectively-Gary/GaryOS/tree/main/data/skills/review-plan/code-pr
Command: npx skills add https://github.com/Collectively-Gary/GaryOS --skill review-plan-code-pr

SYSTEM DOCUMENTATION & REQUIREMENTS

What problem does it solve?

This Skill helps ensure a proposed pull-request plan is actionable, deterministic, and testable before execution, reducing the chance of wasted effort and low-quality PR attempts.

Core Features & Use Cases

  • Plan-focused critique: Reviews the submitted plan artifact (the latest stage plan and captured context refs) rather than the author’s intent.
  • Approach-discipline gate for code-pr: Rejects plans missing required mechanics like clone-and-branch steps, gh pr create, and deterministic decision points tied to exact Approach values.
  • Weighted rubric approval: Scores completeness, scope, edge cases, plausibility, reuse, and test-plan quality, rejecting below a 0.70 threshold and escalating approval quality accordingly.
  • Operator-oriented outcomes: Never advances to awaiting_operator; instead it either rejects for iteration or approves (clean or with concerns) based on rubric results.

Quick Start

Use the review-plan / code-pr Skill to critique a PR plan artifact for playbook: code-pr and return an approval or rejection with dimension scores.

Frequently Asked Questions about review-plan / code-pr

High-intent search queries and answers about installing and using this skill.

FAQPage Schema
How do I review a pull request plan before execution?▼

Reviewing a pull request plan before execution involves checking that it includes clone-and-branch steps, a deterministic approach, and a runnable test strategy. This Skill automates that critique using a weighted rubric to reject or approve the plan artifact.

What is a deterministic approach in a GitHub PR plan?▼

A deterministic approach in a GitHub PR plan requires decision points tied to exact values, avoiding ambiguity during execution. This Skill enforces an approach-discipline gate to ensure your plan meets these deterministic requirements before approval.

Can I use a weighted rubric to score PR plan quality?▼

Yes, you can use a weighted rubric to score PR plan quality across dimensions like completeness, scope, edge cases, and test-plan quality. This Skill applies a 0.70 threshold to reject low-quality plans or approve them with escalating concerns.

Does the plan review process advance to awaiting operator status?▼

The plan review process does not advance to awaiting operator status. Based on the rubric scoring results, this Skill either rejects the plan for iteration or returns a clean approval or an approval with concerns.

Why does my code-pr plan get rejected during automated review?▼

Your code-pr plan gets rejected during automated review if it lacks required mechanics like clone-and-branch steps, gh pr create commands, or a deterministic test strategy. This Skill enforces these approach-discipline checks and rejects plans scoring below a 0.70 rubric threshold.

What components are required in a test plan for a pull request?▼

Required components in a test plan for a pull request include a runnable test strategy and deterministic decision points. This Skill critiques your plan artifact to ensure these elements are present before applying its weighted rubric approval.

Related Skills

Explore More Software Engineering Skills→
ectoecto
34

firmware-review

Review BVR firmware for safety-critical systems and CAN protocol compliance.

Community
Advanced
inakaminakam

create-pr

Analyze branch changes and generate structured GitHub pull requests via gh pr create.

Community
Advanced
dopsonbrdopsonbr
1

review-implementation

Validate implementation work against plan specifications with Codex CLI reviews.

Community
Intermediate
mgd34msumgd34msu
6

review-scoring

Score code reviews across 10 dimensions with weighted criteria and deterministic markdown validation.

Community
Advanced