review-paper

To get a comprehensive manuscript review, provide your paper.pdf or paper.tex file path. The skill evaluates argument quality, identification strategy, and econometric specification, generating a referee-style review report saved to quality_reports/paper_review_[sanitized_name].md.

An automated referee report checks econometric specification, identification strategy, and citation completeness. It evaluates six dimensions including argument structure, literature positioning, and writing clarity, generating 3-5 referee objections for your manuscript.

Yes, you can review a manuscript draft from TEX sources or PDF files. The skill accepts paper.pdf, paper.tex, or filenames in master_supporting_docs/, running automated checks to produce structured feedback and a detailed review report.

The best way to identify potential referee objections is running an automated review across six evaluation dimensions. The skill produces 3-5 specific referee objections targeting econometric rigor and argument quality, outputting a complete report for reproducibility.

The manuscript review tool is applicable to academic papers in economics and related disciplines. It focuses on econometric specification and identification strategy, making it most suitable for quantitative research submissions in those fields.

The generated referee review report is saved to quality_reports/paper_review_[sanitized_name].md. This ensures traceability and satisfies a reproducible workflow for your manuscript evaluation and critique process.